LAKEAIR CIGAR LOUNGE CASE STUDY
A project-specific air-purification and makeup-air strategy helped a new cigar lounge move forward without the roughly $80,000 additional cost of a proposed dedicated outdoor air system.
Jacob Hark set out to build The Cigar Room as a premium cigar-lounge experience in Blaine, Minnesota. The room had to feel intentional, not improvised: a place customers could enjoy, operators could manage, and the project team could confidently build.
Before construction decisions became permanent, Jacob brought LakeAir into the planning conversation. He shared the room information and renderings so the air-quality system could be considered as part of the lounge—not added later as an afterthought. That early decision gave the project a chance to begin with the room Jacob wanted to create.
LakeAir’s original design did not begin with a DOAS. It centered on eight ducted LAAS-1600 smoke eaters, selected and distributed for the lounge itself. The aim was to capture and clean the smoking load where it was generated while preserving the look and function of a finished cigar lounge.
This was an integrated design conversation from the start. The system had to account for the room, expected use, duct paths, equipment placement, and the building’s existing mechanical capabilities. The question was never simply which machine to sell. It was how to build an air-quality strategy that fit Jacob’s project.
THE UNEXPECTED OBSTACLE
As the project moved forward, the contractor insisted that Jacob would need a dedicated outdoor air system, or DOAS. That conclusion introduced roughly $80,000 in additional ventilation-system cost and threatened the economics of the build-out.
For Jacob, the issue was no longer just equipment selection. The system that had been planned for his lounge was suddenly being treated as insufficient, and the path forward appeared to require a major new mechanical expense. Rather than accept that assumption at face value, LakeAir looked for the engineering basis behind it.
LakeAir’s position was that the contractor had not recognized the IMC 403.2 exception relevant to this project. In plain terms, that exception can allow an engineered air-cleaning and recirculation approach to reduce the outdoor makeup-air requirement when the project satisfies the applicable conditions. In a Teams meeting, Randolph Bush pushed for that exception to be considered rather than allowing the DOAS requirement to become an untested conclusion.
Randy then spoke directly with the local inspector about the proposed approach. The goal was not to bypass engineering, code review, or inspection. It was to determine whether the project could use a legitimate engineered solution that accounted for the building’s existing rooftop equipment and the eight-unit LakeAir smoke-control system.
THE RESOLUTION
The final approach was reviewed through the project’s mechanical-engineering and City of Blaine review process, then approved for the build-out. The eight ducted LAAS-1600 units remained the smoke-cleaning foundation of the design.
For makeup air, one of the building’s overhead rooftop units already had economizer capability. That existing RTU could serve the project’s makeup-air need. No ERV was required as part of the LakeAir equipment package. With each part assigned its proper job, the system became a practical whole: existing rooftop equipment for makeup air and distributed ducted LakeAir units for smoke purification.
By validating the engineered alternative instead of accepting the proposed DOAS path, Jacob was able to move forward with the lounge without that estimated additional ventilation-system expense.
Facility: The Cigar Room
Location: Blaine, Minnesota
Project type: New premium cigar lounge
Lounge area: Approximately 1,800 square feet
Ceiling height: 10 feet
Air-cleaning goal: 26 air changes per hour (ACH)
Original LakeAir design: Eight ducted LAAS-1600 units
Later obstacle: Proposed DOAS requirement
Makeup-air strategy: Existing overhead RTU with economizer capability
ERV required: No
Outcome: Approved engineered approach that avoided an estimated $80,000 DOAS cost path
The savings figure describes this project’s comparison between the proposed DOAS direction and the accepted LakeAir approach. It is project-specific, not a current LakeAir quotation.
The Cigar Room was not a story about finding a shortcut. It was a story about asking the right question before an expensive assumption became permanent. Cigar-lounge planning works best when air purification, makeup air, existing HVAC capabilities, mechanical engineering, and municipal review are considered together.
If you are planning a cigar lounge, send LakeAir your floor plan, ceiling height, expected occupancy, and information on existing HVAC equipment. We will help you begin the air-quality conversation before an expensive assumption becomes a construction decision.
Plan Your Cigar Lounge Environment